For those who do not know, the gay scene is usually split into a number of subcultures. Twinks, circuit boys, clubbers, gym bunnies, fetish... The list is endless. One of the biggest sub cultures is Bears and their admirers. Bears are men who like to be men and have hair and as much as possible. Stereotypically they are also fat but there are also muscle bears. Not surprisingly, Bear City puts bear culture at the centre stage. It tells the story of Tyler, a 21 year old twink who has a bear fetish. It deals with him 'coming out' to his other twinky friends as a bear lover or 'chubby chaser', him trying to integrate with the bear community and falling for the top bear.
It is clear that this film was made in order to represent the bear community and to offer an alternative to the perfect, hairless bodies that are usually presented in TLA Releases films. However, for me, it completely misses the mark. It reminds me of late 1980s/early 1990s gay films where there was hardly any films where gay men were at the centre of the story. Those films revolved completely around their sexuality without any other layers to make the characters interesting. Bear City seems to have done exactly the same thing. The only problem with this is that there have been a number of decent films where bears were the main characters, Boystown and Bear Cub were particularly good. These films, although were centred around the bear scene, still managed to cover issues that were not all bear related. Bear City has gone a step back from that and the characters look a bit too one dimensional because of it. The film could have developed other story lines to give the characters some depth while still showing in your face bear sex scenes and lifestyles.
The second issue I have, and it is not the first film to do this, is the focus on Tyler. The film is trying to make the point that gay sub cultures reject people sexually who do not conform with that particular 'look'. The way Roger rejects Tyler at the start because he cannot be seen dating a non bear is portrayed as shallow, but when Tyler rejects his best friend who is a twink, there is no judgement at all. This occurs in a lot of gay films where the smart and funny guy gets rejected by the stud until his full personality is exposed and the stud falls for him. Of course, no film ever makes the smart and funny guy go for another smart and funny guy who also does not have the body.
What does make this film is the performance of Stephen Guarino, who plays Brent, a chubby chaser who is discussing with his partner whether to open their relationship up. His performance is hilarious and he has really been able to give some excellent one liners. I really hope this helps with his acting career because his performance was superb. The rest of the cast were slightly wooden, but he really helped make this film slightly enjoyable
I suppose for any bear and their admirers, Bear City is probably a breath of fresh air where hairy and fat men are sexualised and unapologetically, put at the centre of the film. Not being a bear myself, it will not have the same sort of representation factor for me and perhaps there should be more characters to reflect the diversity of the LGBT communities in more films. However, I am not a fan of making films for the sake of representation. Give some bears a leading role in films and stop being so segregated!
3/5 - Perhaps you need to be bear to really enjoy this!
No comments:
Post a Comment